1 real PYQ·3 concepts ↓·1 concept drill·Asked 2017
📝 Drill the PYQs
Reservation Provisions
Loading questions...
📚 The concepts · 3
tap any tile for full passage
Special Representation for Anglo-Indians
›The President can nominate two members of the Anglo-Indian community to the Lok Sabha if the community is not adequately represented.
›The Governor of a state can nominate one member of the Anglo-Indian community to the state legislative assembly if the community is not adequately represented.
›These provisions were originally designed to operate for ten years (until 1960) but have been extended continuously.
+ 4 facts · tap to read
▾ Full passage
Special Representation for Anglo-Indians is a constitutional provision that grants the Anglo-Indian community representation in the Lok Sabha and state legislative assemblies through nomination, rather than through election. Unlike the reservation system provided to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, the Anglo-Indian community receives special representation because, as a numerically extremely small community dispersed throughout India, it would be unable to secure seats through the electoral process.
The Constitution defines an Anglo-Indian as "a person whose father or any of whose other male progenitors in the male line is or was of European descent but who is domiciled within the territory of India and is or was born within such territory of parents habitually resident therein and not established there for temporary purposes only." The rationale for this special provision recognizes that Anglo-Indians constitute a religious, social, and linguistic minority requiring constitutional protection to ensure their voice in legislatures.
The President of India can nominate up to two members of the Anglo-Indian community to the Lok Sabha if the community is not adequately represented. Similarly, the Governor of a state can nominate one member of the Anglo-Indian community to the state legislative assembly under the same condition. Originally intended to operate for ten years until 1960, this provision has been extended repeatedly. Under the 95th Amendment Act of 2009, special representation for Anglo-Indians was extended until 2020, with the justification that although progress has been made, the reasons necessitating this provision have not ceased to exist.
All key facts
›The President can nominate two members of the Anglo-Indian community to the Lok Sabha if the community is not adequately represented.
›The Governor of a state can nominate one member of the Anglo-Indian community to the state legislative assembly if the community is not adequately represented.
›These provisions were originally designed to operate for ten years (until 1960) but have been extended continuously.
›Under the 95th Amendment Act of 2009, special representation for Anglo-Indians was extended until 2020.
Claims of SCs and STs to Services and Posts
›The claims of SCs and STs for appointments to public services of the Centre and states are to be considered. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
›This consideration should not sacrifice the efficiency of administration. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
›The 82nd Amendment Act of 2000 made a provision for relaxation in qualifying marks or lowering of evaluation standards for SCs and STs. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
+ 2 facts · tap to read
▾ Full passage
Article 335 of the Constitution of India addresses the claims of Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) regarding appointments to services and posts under the Union and the states. It mandates that their claims must be taken into consideration while making these appointments. However, this consideration should not compromise the efficiency of administration. To further facilitate their representation and ensure administrative efficiency is not an absolute bar, the 82nd Amendment Act of 2000 introduced a provision. This amendment allows for relaxation in qualifying marks in examinations or lowering of evaluation standards specifically for SCs and STs, when considering them for reservations in matters of promotion to public services at both the Central and state levels.
All key facts
Special Provisions for Certain Classes (SCs, STs, OBCs, Anglo-Indians)
›**SCs/STs not specified in Constitution** — President specifies by notification after consulting Governor; any change only by Parliament (Laxmikant p.1127)
›**102nd Amendment Act, 2018**: Inserted Article 342A — empowered President to specify OBCs (socially and educationally backward classes) in relation to a state or union territory (Laxmikant p.1127)
+ 30 facts · tap to read
▾ Full passage
Part XVI of the Constitution (Articles 330–342A) contains special provisions for Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), Backward Classes (BCs/OBCs), and Anglo-Indians. These provisions aim to realise the Preamble's objectives of equality and justice. They cover reservation in legislatures, special representation, reservation in services/posts, educational grants, and national commissions. Some provisions are **permanent** (reservation for SCs/STs in services), while others are **temporary** (seat reservations in legislatures, originally for 10 years, periodically extended).
The specification of which castes/tribes constitute SCs and STs is left to the President (by notification, after consulting the Governor). Parliament — not a subsequent Presidential notification — must make any addition or exclusion. The 102nd Amendment Act 2018 similarly empowered the President to specify OBCs.
Special provisions can be classified as **Permanent and Temporary** (some are permanent features while others operate for specified periods) and **Protective and Developmental** (some protect from injustice and exploitation while others promote socio-economic interests).
All key facts
›
The National Commission for Scheduled Castes is also required to investigate all matters relating to constitutional and legal safeguards for the Anglo-Indian community and report to the President.
›The constitutional definition of Anglo-Indian specifies descent through the male line from European ancestors, domicile within Indian territory, and birth within India to parents habitually resident there.
›Special Representation for Anglo-Indians is governed by Articles 331 (Lok Sabha) and 333 (state legislative assemblies) of the Constitution.
›
The claims of SCs and STs for appointments to public services of the Centre and states are to be considered. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
›This consideration should not sacrifice the efficiency of administration. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
›The 82nd Amendment Act of 2000 made a provision for relaxation in qualifying marks or lowering of evaluation standards for SCs and STs. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
›This relaxation applies to reservations in matters of promotion to public services of the Centre and states. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
›Article 335 of the Constitution deals with the claims of SCs and STs to services and posts. (M. Laxmikanth — Indian Polity (6th Edition, 2019), ch68-special-provisions-relating-to-certain-classes.md)
›**SCs/STs not specified in Constitution** — President specifies by notification after consulting Governor; any change only by Parliament (Laxmikant p.1127)
›**102nd Amendment Act, 2018**: Inserted Article 342A — empowered President to specify OBCs (socially and educationally backward classes) in relation to a state or union territory (Laxmikant p.1127)
›**Anglo-Indian definition** (only group constitutionally defined): person whose father or any other male progenitor in the male line is/was of European descent, but domiciled in India and born in India within territory of parents habitually resident therein and not established there for temporary purposes only (Laxmikant p.1127–28)
›**Reservation in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies** for SCs and STs based on population ratios (Laxmikant p.1128)
›President can nominate **2 Anglo-Indians to Lok Sabha**; Governor can nominate **1 Anglo-Indian to State Assembly** if community inadequately represented (Laxmikant p.1128)
›Seat reservations originally for **10 years** (1950–1960); extended multiple times — 95th Amendment Act, 2009 extended to **70 years** (until 2020); 104th Amendment Act, 2019 extended to **80 years** (until 2030) and also abolished Anglo-Indian nomination provisions (Laxmikant p.1128–29)
›**82nd Amendment Act, 2000**: Parliament can provide for relaxation in qualifying marks for SCs/STs in promotion matters (Laxmikant p.1130)
›**National Commission for SCs** (Article 338): investigates constitutional safeguards for SCs and Anglo-Indians (Laxmikant p.1130)
›**National Commission for STs** (Article 338-A): investigates constitutional safeguards for STs (Laxmikant p.1130)
›**89th Amendment Act, 2003**: bifurcated the combined SC/ST Commission into two separate bodies (Laxmikant p.1130)
›**National Commission for BCs** (Article 338-B, inserted by 102nd Amendment 2018): constitutional status; originally set up in 1993 by Act of Parliament (Laxmikant p.1131)
›**Kaka Kalelkar Commission (1953)**: First Backward Classes Commission; report 1955; no action taken (Laxmikant p.1132)
›**Mandal Commission (B.P. Mandal, 1979)**: Second Backward Classes Commission; report 1980; V.P. Singh Government declared 27% reservation for OBCs in government jobs in 1990 (Laxmikant p.1132)
›**Dhebar Commission (1960)**: Commission on Scheduled Areas welfare; headed by U.N. Dhebar (Laxmikant p.1131)
›**Special provisions for Anglo-Indians in services and educational grants** were allowed to continue under the Constitution on a progressive diminution basis and ended in 1960 (Laxmikant p.1129)
›**National Commission for SCs** is also required to discharge similar functions for the Anglo-Indian community as it does for SCs, investigating their constitutional and legal safeguards (Laxmikant p.1130)
›**Article 334** states that provisions for reservation of seats for SCs and STs and representation of Anglo-Indians by nomination in legislatures would cease after 60 years from the commencement of the Constitution (January 25, 2010), if not extended (Laxmikant p.1128-1129)
›**Reasons for extension** of reservation and special representation by 95th Amendment Act, 2009: While SCs and STs made considerable progress, the original reasons for reservation/nomination had not ceased to exist (Laxmikant p.1129)
›**Reasons for special Anglo-Indian representation**: Anglo-Indians constitute a religious, social, and linguistic minority, numerically small and interspersed across India, making it difficult to secure seats through election (Laxmikant p.1129)
›**Control of the Union over Scheduled Areas and Welfare of STs**: President appoints a commission to report on administration of scheduled areas and ST welfare; first such commission appointed in 1960 (Dhebar Commission), second in 2002 (Dilip Singh Bhuria) (Laxmikant p.1130-1131)
›**Executive power of the Centre** extends to directing states on schemes for the welfare of STs (Laxmikant p.1131)
›**First Backward Classes Commission (Kaka Kalelkar, 1953)**: submitted report in 1955, but no action was taken as recommendations were considered vague and impractical, and there was division over criteria of backwardness (Laxmikant p.1131)
›**Special provisions classified as Permanent and Temporary**: Some provisions are permanent features while others continue for specified periods (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**Special provisions classified as Protective and Developmental**: Some aim at protecting classes from injustice and exploitation, others aim at promoting socio-economic interests (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**Presidential notification for OBCs** after consultation with Governor; any inclusion or exclusion from Central List only by Parliament, not subsequent Presidential notification (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**Claims of SCs and STs to Services and Posts** must be taken into consideration while making appointments to public services of Centre and states without sacrificing efficiency of administration (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**82nd Amendment Act of 2000** provides for relaxation in qualifying marks in examination or lowering standards of evaluation for reservation in matters of promotion for SCs and STs (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**Anglo-Indian posts before independence** were reserved in railway, customs, postal and telegraph services; Anglo-Indian educational institutions received special grants; both allowed to continue on progressive diminution basis and ended in 1960 (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**National Commissions for SCs and STs** — President should set up commission to investigate constitutional safeguards and report to Parliament with action taken memorandum (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**Previously combined National Commission for SCs and STs** — 89th Amendment Act 2003 bifurcated into two separate bodies (Laxmikant ch.68)
›**National Commission for BC
borrowed featuresconstituent assemblyequality political and socialfunctions of constitutionpreambleindian parliamentary group